Monday, March 10, 2008

Earwigging -- A Mississippi Tradition

Mississippi has a long history of an unusual pratice -- earwigging. Earwigging means "to annoy or attempt to influence by private talk ."

In the past century, Mississippi developed rules of trial practice which were directed toward bringing an end to the practice. The Mississippi Law Journal in 1936 - 1937 discussed such a rule -- for example Chancery Rule 30:

Rule 30.-EARWIGGING THE CHANCELLOR PROHIBITED. No person shall undertake to discuss with or in the presence or hearing of the Chancellor the law or the facts or alleged facts of any litigated cause then pending in the court or likely to be instituted therein, except in the orderly progress of the trial, and arguments or briefs connected therewith; nor attempt in any manner except as above stated, to influence his decision in any such cause or matter. Any person who shall violate this rule, knowing that such conduct is prohibited, shall be guilty of a contempt.

Proceedings of the Thirty-First Annual Meeting of the Mississippi State Bar [comments] ,9 Miss. L.J. 6 (1936-1937)

This rule was commented on as follows:
Some lawyers have ingenious methods of evading this rule, and it is almost impossible sometimes to prevent ignorant laymen from approaching the chancellor about a particular law suit. Almost every term of court someone attempts to talk to me about their cook who has a divorce case in my court, and how much she has been wronged. They always carefully preface their conversation with the statement that they wouldn't try to influence the court for the world.

Id.

Current Mississippi Circuit Court Rules (like other Mississippi court rules) include a rule prohibiting earwigging.

Rule 1.10 EARWIGGING PROHIBITED No person shall undertake to discuss with or in the presence or hearing of the judge the law or the facts or alleged facts of any case then pending in the court or likely to be instituted therein, except in the orderly progress of the trial, and arguments or briefs connected therewith; nor attempt in any manner, except as stated above, to influence the decision of the judge in any such case or matter.

The tradition of earwigging is so common the rules adopted by the Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance include a rule prohibiting earwigging. Commission Rule 5.H "Earwigging Prohibited."

This rule is similar to the Chancery Court rule above regarding punishment for rule violation. Punishment for "knowingly" violating the rule may be "contempt." But, the earlier Chancery rule said if one violated the rule "[he] shall be guilty of contempt."

The current court rules do not have this "contempt" provision. That is to say, a specific punishment is not provided for. Earwigging, is not a misdemeanor or a felony. It is just a rule of court.

So in the Scruggs Litigation what do we have in relation to this historical phenomenon of an usual Mississippi tradition – earwigging?

It seems we may have a situation where a trial judge engaged in earwigging with the attorney(s) for the plaintiff in the Jones v. Scruggs case. Evidence of the earwigging is found in the fact of the very unusual ore tenus motion whereby the judge entered an order sealing the file of the case from all the world open to be unsealed in the sole discretion of the attorney who filed the case.

Next we have the same judge again engaging in earwigging with a person who was a friend of one of the defendants in the action about the case but only such that the judge might know that all the defendant might want in the case was that it be sent to arbitration as provided in the agreement between the parties.

We also have two old friends talking about the retirement of the older friend and the new law firm of the younger friend.

Then, after several days, the judge decides earwigging he had wrongfully engaged in violation of a court rule could lead to something better. An effort to use his friend to bring down a lawyer who was not liked by a segment of the Mississippi bar and judicial system and representatives of the Office of the United States Attorney.

It also may have been a contributing factor that the judge knew his wrongful earwigging could lead to something against him. He was a member of the Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance. The Commission had recently been involved in disciplinary actions where the judge disciplined had engaged in ex parte contact with attorneys and parties.

The judge becomes an agent of the U.S. Attorney. In agreeing to do so, the judge agrees that he will violate the authority of his office, State Judges are not elected act as agents for the government of the united states. He also violates the principles of separation of power between the executive, judicial, and legislative branches of government. And, significantly, on his own he decides it is permissible for him to violate numerous provisions of the Mississippi Code of Judicial Conduct.

Making matters even worse, the judge in question was and is a member of the Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance.

Committed as an agent for the federal government, the judge begins to use his friend to capture the target, Richard Scruggs. The judge pursues his friend.

At first he engages in more earwigging with the attorney for the plaintiff in the Jones Case. He then says he is going to recuse himself and tells his other earwigging partners. This was before he became a government agent. Once an agent, he says he is not going to recuse himself from the case. Obvioulsy, he wanted to pursue his earwigging of his friend, his rule violating earwigging to trap his friend and perhaps his friend's friend.

Weeks go by. During that period, the judge's friend engages in actions which are entirely irrational regarding the creation of a law firm with a non-lawyer. The friend and the non-lawyer write strange and overly aggressive letters to a local lawyer who is criticizing the new law firm and is saying the combination of a lawyer and a non-lawyer in a law firm is a violation of the Mississippi Rules of Professional Conduct.

The judge knows all about his friend's meltdown and he knows of the content of the letters. At this point he then begins to push a scheme whereby he convinces his friend that he is in desperate financial trouble. He needs money and he needs it fast. The young friend goes along and agrees to help. He is now trapped. Aware that another lawyer in the state was just sentenced to 11 years in prison for alleged wrongdoing with a judge he agrees to become involved in the judge's scheme to trap his friend.

If the foregoing is true, what the judge and the federal government have done is extremely troublesome. We cannot have a system of justice due the respect and trust of the people if this sort of conduct is allowed.

81 comments:

Anonymous said...

Percy Lynchard and Malenda Meacham have done this in my case. Lynchard made huge decisions with my child's life, without even hearing testimony from either party. The only way he would have known anything about the case would have been through Meacham outside of any hearing. Please give me advice on how to expose these two, and stop their wrong doings.

Anonymous said...

Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!

Alice Thomas said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Telephone Systems Northeast Mississippi said...

As far as I know, changing/end rules or law is not the easiest way as what they think, it needs more time before it gets final....

kay sieverding said...

My civil lawsuit was in the federal court in Colorado. It was assigned to former judge Naughty Nottingham and Magistrate Schlatter. Nottingham, who was patronizing prostitutes in 2003, according to published affidavits, dismissed my case but he didn't write a memorandum opinion. Nottingham ordered me to pay the bills of David Brougham and Hall & Evans which claimed "immunity" to my claims. There were no rule 11 c. 6 orders and Hall & Evans didn't file a Rule 11 motion. However, they did file their bills and garnish my bank accounts.

In Jan 2003, Magistrate Schlatter issued an order for an oral hearing:
“David Brougham has advised me that in the event that plaintiffs obtain service upon any of the municipal defendants he will be the attorney for such defendants. In light of that fact, I will direct that Mr. Brougham also attend the status conference” p. 7 “order setting status conference 1/10/03
Magistrate Schlatter” Colorado 02- 1950 document 9

The bills that Hall & Evans filed included:

On 2/12/03,:“Review new letter from Sieverding to Tremaine regarding Bennett and may city defendants. Telephone call to Dave Brougham—
discussed pleadings from Wisconsin court and Sieverding letter. Conference call to Magistrate Schlatter." (Lettunich & Vanderbloemen bill attached to document 465)

6/24/03 “Telephone call from Dave Brougham (defense attorney for government defendants) advising me that the Clerk for Magistrate Schlatter advised that no Reply would be necessary”.

2/12/03 “Confer with court clerk regarding new pleadings from plaintiffs”.

3/31/03 “telephone calls to and from Lettunich regarding new filing, telephone call to federal court regarding same"

4/23/03 Telephone call to court regarding status of recent orders”

6/11/03 “Telephone call to court regarding response to motion to compel”

6/16/03 “Telephone call to court regarding 6/15 filing”

6/16/03 “Telephone call to court regarding status of plaintiffs’ response regarding motion to dismiss”

7/2/03 “Telephone call from clerk regarding certain motions”

7/30/03 “Telephone call to Court regarding latest filings”

8/4/03 “Telephone call to court regarding filings by plaintiffs since (7/31) order”.


8/14/03“Confer with court clerk regarding status of ruling on motions”

8/15/03 “Confer with court regarding status of pending motions and timing of ruling”

9/8/03 “Telephone call to court regarding status of pending motions”

9/09/03 “Confer with court regarding status of motions”

9/24/03 “Confer with court regarding status of pending motions)

0/07/03 ‘Confer with court clerk regarding rule status’

10/14/03 “Confer with court clerk regarding filing of recommendation regarding pending motions” (e78, Brougham to CIRSA). That recommendation was issued 10/20.

10/24/03 “review 13 additional ‘motions’ filed by plaintiffs. Telephone call to court regarding status and acceptance or rejection of same.”

11/21/03 “confer with court clerk regarding status of pleadings”

12/11/03 “Review actual court file” “confer with clerks regarding case status, pending motions” “Further conference with court staff regarding motion status”

1/07/04 “Confer with court regarding status of plaintiff pleadings, pending motions, etc. Analyze motion to enjoin grounds, etc.”

The motion to enjoin was never filed but the magistrate "sua sponte" recommended an injunction. That involved threats of violence under color of law if I went to a different court. DOJ USMS division implemented that by jailing me for 5 months without charging me with an offense or having an arraignment or bail hearing. The stated reason is that I tried to get an evidentiary hearing from a different court and that I "sued lawyers".

I think USMS deprived my rights because of their functions in escorting and guarding former Judge Nottingham when he went to brothels and/or strip clubs. Maybe someone took a photo of a USMS officer with a prostitute or stripper and then blackmailed him.

Dean said...

Great ....You have beautifully presented your thought in this blog post.payday loan direct lender

tupbebek said...

I am happy to find this very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content
ada..

payday said...

can see the pac 10 wanting to expand. It is such a weak conference, the only ones who are impressed by them are the reporters who rank usc in the top 5 preseason every year payday loan lenders

Whitney said...

It was my first experience and I got success.. I enjoyed very much... Thanks.
payday loan lenders

Dexter said...

earwigging is found in the fact of the very unusual ore tenus motion whereby the judge entered an order sealing the file of the case from all the world open to be unsealed in the sole discretion
no fax same day payday loans

Ned said...

Great....You have beautifully presented your thought in this blog post.cash payday loan

khan22 said...

Almost every term of court someone attempts to talk to me about their cook who has a divorce case in my court, and how much she has been wronged.
Carlsbad Bankruptcy Attorney

khan22 said...

they were is a pure fiction, a fiction necessary to make the case against Dick Scruggs, Sidney Backstrom and Zach Scruggs -- a fiction necessary for the government to win the war.
San Diego Podiatrist

turbofire said...

Can I make a suggestion? I think youve got something good here. But what if you added a couple links to a page that backs up what youre saying? Or maybe you could give us something to look at, something that would connect what youre saying to something tangible? Just a suggestion.

nasim said...

they were is a pure fiction, a fiction necessary to make the case against Dick Scruggs, Sidney Backstrom and Zach Scruggs -- a fiction necessary for the government to win the war.
Bankruptcy San Diego

nasim said...

I think you are overlooking a more important issue here, I would like to hear more about the Digital Dealer curse.
Bankruptcy San Diego

Anonymous said...

Thats great, I never knew before this blog.
Push Up Bra

youlacka said...

That is really very good article.kızlarla chat,I am glad to know.mersin chat,Thanks for sharing !avrupa chat

Brochure Design said...

The judge seems to be clever. Used his friend for official purpose.

water said...

in the action about the case but only such that the judge might know that all the defendant might want case was that it be sent to arbitration in the agreement between the parties.
Carbon Fiber Paddle

meal replacement shake said...

Thank You a ton for writing such a wonderful piece of information. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

Dog Life Jacket said...

they were is a pure fiction, a fiction necessary to make the case against Dick Scruggs, Sidney Backstrom and Zach Scruggs -- a fiction necessary for the government to win the war.

rose said...

Absolutely I am happy to find this very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content
Ada..
SARONG

rose said...

Lot Of Thanks...... I have not quite understand about your article but from the little that I read I can understand what she meant.
Austin Real Estate

tax attorney said...

It is nice to find a site about my interest. My first visit to your site is been a big help. Thank you for the efforts you been putting on making your site such an interesting and informative place to browse through. I'll be visiting your site again to gather some more valuable information. You truly did a good job.

Anonymous said...

There's no word to describe such a great masterpiece. You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject an enlightenment for us to gain knowledge and information without any arguments to deal with. Thank you very much and more power!

loans till payday | android app developers

Jerry said...

Quite possibly the most succinct and current info I came across about this subject. Sure pleased that I discovered that site by accident. I’ll probably be subscribing for your feed so that I will get the most current updates. Like the information here.
car title loans | rims financing

man said...

As far as I know, changing/end rules or law is not the easiest way as what they think, it needs more time before it gets final Thanks.
Austin Custom Home Builders

Anonymous said...

Quite possibly the most succinct and current info I came across about this subject. Sure pleased that I discovered that site by accident. I’ll probably be subscribing for your feed so that I will get the most current updates. Like the information here.
car title loan | rim financing

Self assessment tax return said...

This is definitely a blog worth following. You've got a great deal to say about this subject, and you can also tell that by the huge number of comments!

Bonbons said...

Great to see such a wonderful approach.

Acheter xenical said...

Hi guys, I want to say thanks for this useful information, I shared it on my wall to be honnest cause I LIKE it(:

Corian Worktops said...

Too bad you don't write that much anymore.

Buy Viagra said...

Thanks for sharing, much appreciated and useful post, congrat and keep on track!

Asbestos Training said...

I am so thrilled for having found your site.

Xavi said...

Nice entry!!
And nice tradition!! Congrats for the blog!

Website Designer Bahrain said...

Thanks for the post.History is my passion.I love read this type of topics.
Website Designer Bahrain

dubaiexperies said...

they were is a pure fiction, a fiction necessary to make the case against Dick Scruggs, Sidney Backstrom and Zach Scruggs -- a fiction necessary for the government to win the war.
Abilene Roofing Companies

Tax Return said...

Thanks for sharing your unique point of view on this subject.

Play Sand said...

I have spend 15 wonderful minutes reading your post. You've done a terrific job!

Asbestos Removal said...

I can not keep this blog just for myself, so I'll forward it to all of my friends

Erica Francis said...

LOL, I just heard of the term 'earwigging' from my cousin who just moved down near Georgia, I think its awesome :)

dumpster rental said...

Nice post keep up with this good work.Very Nice Blog.

Air Conditioning Cost Greenwood Indiana said...

The arrest of prominent Mississippi attorney Richard “Dickie” Scruggs was a stunning and dramatic event. We should be watchful with our actions now.

Test SAP said...

I can't wait to read your next post on this topic.

Office Supplies said...

You're such an amazing blogger. You should write as often as possible.

Accountants in London said...

You are focused on realizing all you possibly can about this. We're completely satisfied you discovered us.

On this site, we have introduced collectively an unlimited array of data and sources on this.

Accountants in London

Anonymous said...

Nike Free plus 2
Cheap Nike free
Nike free run shoes
Nike free run sale
women nike free run sale
Nike Free Run 2

Find a tradesman app said...

I like your site a lot. However, it is not quite accessible on mobile devices. You should do something about that. Cheers and nothing but the best.

Remy hair extensions said...

Nice post keep up with this good work.Very Nice Blog. It shows the standard of author that how he involved in this topic heartily. Thank you very much for this

how to play the piano said...

nice post and very decent also thank you a lot for share

accounting said...

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well.


Cuscowilla on lake oconee

Affordable Logo Design said...

This is one of the highly informatics and attractive blogs that has not only educated also informed me in a very effective manner. There are very few blog like this one I have read.

Craig Pattinson said...

He was very well written and easy to understand. Unlike other blogs I’ve read that are not really good. I also found interesting your blogs.


Houston Electrician

Nashville Air Conditioning, said...

Details are very true and factual, I do really learned something new upon reading this interesting post. Good job! and Thanks!


http://www.frogheatingandair.com'<Nashville Air Conditioning,

fix credit said...

is that where the expression " put a bug in your ear" comes from.

Toner Cartridges said...

This is an awesome article. You should write more often on this.

Hire magento designer said...

This post is great. Thank you for this post. I like this type of people who share knowledge with others.

Entertainment Agency said...

This is an awesome article.

Employment Solicitors Slough said...

Next time you approach this topic, please send me an email.

Joomla Developer said...

Great article.I like your thoughts and it's really great.Great discussion.Thanks for sharing.

iphone accessories said...

that's really great post I got so much information about Mississippi Earwigging. great post to enhance my knowledge base.

HelpFixAnyPC | PC Repair Leicester said...

This is really an amazing post , I really like this, the words you write here are really very clear to everyone , thanks for sharing this great post with us.

Meme Estetiği said...

I enjoyed this site. Çene Cerrahisi I will recommend your site to other places. Saç Ekim Everyone does not show care. Estetik But you were preparing a site so rich in content. Estetik Burun Ameliyatı Everyone who helped, thank you.

Hotels in Ibiza Town said...

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the

future as well.

Hotels in Ibiza Townss

Joomla developer said...

Great site.Thanks for sharing your wonderful information.

skip hire prices said...

This is so strange tradition. Well I would surely research some more facts about it as I am finding it really interesting.

Male Breast Reduction said...

I love your post so much, that I've sent it to all my friends.

Craig Pattinson said...

Nice stuff you got, very interesting to read.Well, I do have also in my sleeves, if you have time don't forget to visit

apartamentos lanzarote

health insurance california said...

Pretty cool post. It’s really very nice and useful post.Thanks for sharing this with us!it’s my first visit.

Wedding Photographer Maidenhead said...

I must admit you are a terrific blogger! I wish I had the same skills!

Hotel Washington Dc said...

You are sharing such nice post. The data supplied was very useful. Continue in the same spirit.

food recipes said...

I'm so excited to find your blog, I couldn't find so worthy information on this matter. This is perfect job, your post is just what I was looking for!

birçok tıp sektöründe said...

Comments made ??about the issues impressed me. I like your site.
tr

Orlando Outlet said...

It's interesting to read.. it's really nice I like it. I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job ...

fix credit said...

Increase credit score and save money. Your credit score largely determines the lenders available and the interest rate at which they will lend. Fix credit and expand the number of lenders willing to compete for your loan.

Coach Outlet Store Online said...

It's really a good post. I have learnt a lot from it. I will recommend it to my firends. Hope they ill like it too.

Blog said...

m a big fan of the blog. Im a frequent visitor and its bookmarked on my google tool bar lol. Keep up the good work resimler yemek tarifleri moda merkezisağlık parfüm bebek bakımı güzellik bilgileri parfüm markaları magazin hayat bilgileri magazin dünyası

Dumpster Rental Westchester said...

Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read. I hope you will post again soon. Dumpster Rental Westchester

business voip systems said...

I Like your blog,will sharing this with my friends, excellent work.
business voip systems

cherry said...

i was reading the blog and i think that this information is going to help me a lot.

www.n8fan.net